When local council elections occur in an area without concurrent elections for Mayoral Combined Authorities (MCAs) or other regional bodies, the MCA is still partially bound by the pre-election period rules. That is because MCAs are local authorities within the meaning of section 6 of the Local Government Act 1986. They are therefore subject to the same publicity restrictions in section 2 of the Local Government Act 1986 and are required by section 4 of that Act to have regard to the Code of Recommended Practice’s principles of impartiality and fairness during the pre-election period. That is not confined to publicity affecting MCA elections.
Scope of restrictions
While constituent councils facing elections are strictly bound by pre-election rules, MCAs are also required to act impartially and avoid activities that could influence the constituent council election outcome. Adhering to these rules ensures fairness and maintains public trust in the integrity of the electoral process.
The restrictions on MCAs are generally less stringent than those on the constituent councils who are holding the election, but MCAs must still act cautiously to avoid influencing the election. Even actions not directly related to the election could be perceived as influential, necessitating careful consideration.
The Cabinet Office guidance is applicable to all public bodies. For example, an MCA mayor should avoid making public statements about local council candidates or issues central to the election.
How pre-election rules might apply to MCAs:
Impartiality and fairness: Even if they are not holding elections. avoid activities that could be perceived as influencing the local council elections.
Restrictions on publicity and communications: MCAs should refrain from issuing publicity or making announcements that could influence voters in the local council elections or appear to favour or oppose specific candidates, parties, or issues. For instance, an MCA should avoid launching new policies or initiatives that could benefit a particular political group or candidate.
Limitations on decision-making: MCAs should avoid making politically sensitive decisions during the pre-election period, especially if these decisions could impact local council elections. This includes postponing high-profile announcements, major policy changes, or significant spending decisions.
Neutrality in public statements: MCA officials, including the mayor, must maintain political neutrality in their public statements and actions during the pre-election period. They should avoid commenting on issues or candidates related to the local council elections in a manner that could be seen as partisan.
Engagement with local councils: While MCAs may need to engage with local councils during the pre-election period, they must ensure that such engagement is impartial and does not influence the elections.
Guidance from the Cabinet Office: MCAs should adhere to Cabinet Office guidance on the pre-election period, applicable to all public bodies, regardless of their direct involvement in the elections.
Constituent councils: The councils holding elections are directly bound by pre-election period rules and must follow stricter restrictions. These councils must avoid any activities that could influence the election outcome, including publicity, decision-making, and public statements.