All councillors are responsible for ensuring the effectiveness of the authority’s governance. Ensuring effective leadership and oversight of council finances is a key aspect of good governance in local government. Councils are legally required to achieve best value in relation to the use of their funding. When financial management ‘fails’ publicly then councillors are often in the ‘hot seat.’ But exactly who does what in relation to finance? What are the roles of the cabinet or policy and resources committee, of the resources portfolio, committee chairs and of non-finance portfolio holders? This part of the workbook explores these key questions.
What are the financial roles and responsibilities of non-finance portfolio holders?
New portfolio holders and committee chairs in local authorities rarely receive a comprehensive induction in which all their roles and responsibilities are clearly set out from the start. Instead, the usual practice is ‘learning on the job’ and – often – continuing the predecessor's pattern of work. The financial aspects of the role can often seem opaque, unclear, and rather technical. Given the high workload of many portfolio holders, it is easy for them to fall into a pattern of ‘receiving and reacting’ to financial information rather than ‘being proactive and leading.’ It is not unusual to assume that financial governance is predominantly the preserve of the resources portfolio holder and finance officers.
A good starting point for a portfolio holder who wants to fully understand and explore their financial role is to assess the current situation and what responsibilities are set out in the council’s constitution.
As a first step, write down your answers to Challenge 1 below.
Challenge 1
The constitutional role
- What does your council’s constitution state about your roles and responsibilities in relation to finance?
- If there is a cabinet member role description and/or terms of reference in the constitution, does this include reference to finance?
- What do the financial regulations state in relation to councillors’ roles?
- What are the procurement rules and what role do councillors have in them?
Financial responsibilities in practice
- Reflect upon whether you can see that what is set out in the constitution is happening 'on the ground'. Where are the gaps and overlaps?
Key challenges
- What key challenges do you face in performing your financial roles?
- What actions could you take to address these challenges?
Leadership of portfolio resources – Ten key roles
Be 'proactive and leading' on finances rather than 'reactive and receiving'
A councillor in a senior role aiming to be ‘proactive and leading,' rather than 'reactive and receiving’ will be looking to undertake the 10 key roles summarised below. These range from knowledge-based roles such as ‘understanding the general picture of local government finance’ to relationship-building through ‘developing effective relationships with key finance officers’ and understanding a range of systems and processes, for example, ‘understanding your council’s financial processes.’
A non-finance portfolio holder or committee chair should aim to:
- understand the general picture of local government finances
- understand their council's financial processes
- become adept in leading consideration of finance matters in relation to their portfolio or service committee area
- access and understand key financial information in relation to their portfolio or service committee area
- champion integration of finance and service information
- oversee financial aspects of major projects
- understand income and commercialisation in relation to their service area
- oversee financial risk
- understand partnerships and finance
- develop effective relationships with key finance officers.
A non-finance portfolio holder or committee chair will work more effectively if they:
- understand how the council’s financial processes operate
- are familiar with the stages of the budget-making process
- are aware of the assumptions underpinning the council’s medium-term financial strategy
- are knowledgeable about the key financial documents
- understand how their own portfolio or service budget is constructed
- ensure they obtain timely financial information
- are involved in budgetary discussions at key points
- act as a champion for integrating financial and service information
- search for value for money
- ensure that 'the money follows’ political priorities.
There are a range of specialised roles relating to aspects of financial governance, including:
- ensuring effective risk management and providing political leadership of risk
- considering approaches to income generation and commercialisation in the portfolio or service area
- carefully managing major projects and ensuring they are supported with robust business plans
- understanding how working with outside agencies impacts upon finances, for example, through pooled budgets
More detail on each of the ten roles is provided below.
Leadership of portfolio finances – 10 key roles framework
1. Understanding the general picture of local government finances
To succeed in this role, a portfolio holder or committee chair should:
- have oversight of the ‘big picture’ concerning national local government finance
- be aware of upcoming changes in legislation or regulations which may impact financial planning or service delivery
2. Understanding your council's financial processes
To succeed in this role, a portfolio holder or committee chair should:
- understand the council’s medium term financial strategy
- understand the council's council-wide budget process and timetable
- be familiar with the council's key financial documents, for example, relevant sections of the constitution and the financial regulations
- take responsibility for corporate financial and governance processes relating to their portfolio or service area, for example, delivering savings and risk management.
3. Becoming adept with their portfolio or committee’s financial leadership
To succeed in this role, a portfolio holder or committee chair should:
- understand how their portfolio budget is constructed
- ensure that priority-setting is informed by resource availability
4. Accessing and understanding key portfolio financial information
To succeed in this role, a portfolio holder or committee chair should:
- ensure they have access to timely financial information which is presented clearly and effectively.
5. Championing integration of finance and service information
To succeed in this role, a portfolio holder or committee chair should:
- act as a champion for integrating finance and service information, for example, ask for unit costs of services
- ensure a focus on delivering ‘value for money’
- ensure that budgetary decisions follow political priorities
- ensure that finance, performance, and risk information are all monitored regularly
6. Overseeing financial aspects of major projects
To succeed in this role, a portfolio holder or committee chair should:
- ensure that the financial aspects of major projects are carefully project-planned with robust business plans and monitoring of delivery.
7. Understanding income and commercialisation
To succeed in this role, a portfolio holder or committee chair should:
- lead politically on income generation and commercialisation activities in your portfolio or service area, ensuring appropriate due diligence and governance.
8. Overseeing financial risk
To succeed in this role, a portfolio holder or committee chair should:
- understand the council’s risk management processes and approaches
- lead politically on identifying and ensuring appropriate mitigation of risk as it relates to their portfolio or service area
9. Understanding partnerships and finance
To succeed in this role, a portfolio holder or committee chair should:
- consider the financial implications of partnership-working
- work to ‘lever’ finance through collaboration.
10. Developing effective relationships with key finance officers
To succeed in this role, a portfolio holder or committee chair should:
- develop an effective working relationship with the council's section 151 officer
- develop an effective working relationship with their ‘business partner’ (their portfolio finance manager)
- Understanding the ‘dual role’ of the finance department and its culture (see below)
Developing your financial leadership skills
How can new portfolio holders or committee chairs, or those less confident about the financial aspects of their role, develop knowledge and skills in this area?
It can be helpful to consider that in undertaking the 10 key roles, you can frame your development journey in terms of:
- building knowledge
- understanding key systems and processes
- developing effective relationships.
Potential actions to develop your confidence in undertaking your financial roles are suggested below.
- reading the key financial aspects of your council's constitution – particularly the scheme of delegation
- reviewing corporate budget monitoring and budget setting reports to your council and / or cabinet or committees
- meeting with the lead officer(s) for your portfolio/ service area to gain an overview of how your portfolio budgets are developed and monitored.
- meeting with your council's finance or resources portfolio holder or finance committee chair to fully understand your financial roles
- researching and understanding the role different parts of the governance system play in financial decision-making and oversight, for example, your council's audit committee and overview and scrutiny functions
- undertaking the LGA councillor workbook on local government finance.
- attending courses such as the LGA ‘Finance without Numbers’ programme and/or our two part online Financial Governance Leadership Essentials programme
Another approach to developing and evaluating your financial skills is set out in Challenge 2 below.
Challenge 2 – The 10 key roles as a personal development tool
Appendix 1 (see below) sets out a self-evaluation framework for portfolio holders / committee chairs to use as a personal development tool.
For each of the 10 Key Roles you are encouraged to consider:
- How well are you undertaking this role?
- What evidence would you provide to support this?
- What further actions could you take? When?
In addition, this workbook contains many suggestions which will grow your knowledge, skills, and confidence in portfolio financial leadership.
Financial Governance: The Four Faces of Cabinet Working
In a council with the cabinet model, governance works on a number of levels and financial roles and responsibilities are weaved into these different levels. ‘The four faces of cabinet-working,’ set out below, demonstrates the different levels and interplays between cabinet members and senior officers. Good financial leadership by a cabinet partly rests on clarity of the respective roles and responsibilities of the non-finance portfolio holder, the collective cabinet, and the finance portfolio holder.
Which of the roles listed below does what concerning finances and the budget?
- the finance portfolio holder
- the collective cabinet
- individual non-finance portfolio holder and senior officer
- top team (i.e. cabinet plus senior management team)
The 10 key roles framework sets out the roles of the non-finance portfolio holder, but each portfolio holder also has the responsibility to work collectively with the cabinet (and top team) in the following areas.
The role of the collective cabinet
The cabinet, when meeting and working collectively, should:
- propose the budget (alongside the policy framework) for agreement by full council
- ensure a balanced budget is agreed
- ensure the achievement of value for money and best value
- discuss and agree overall budget strategy
- set the overall strategy for income generation and commercialisation, risk management, major projects, procurement, and so on
- agree and drive forward a consistent, coherent political strategy for the council to guide budget decisions.
The role of the resources portfolio holder
In addition to the four faces of cabinet described above, the cabinet member with responsibility for finances (sometimes known as the resources portfolio holder) has a pivotal role to play in the council’s governance. In essence, they are the lead councillor with responsibility for effective financial management and governance. To be effective, they work closely with senior finance officers, and need to develop effective relationships with other portfolio holders and non-finance senior officers.
In a committee system of governance, a service committee chair would also need to consider how their role in financial governance relates to the different roles of other committees. In a committee system where there is a policy and resources committee with a particular role for finance and risk then there is a need to consider what does the policy and resources committee do separately from a service committee? Some policy and resources committees include the chairs and vice chairs from the main service committees. If this is the case, then considering what is done collectively and what is done within the individual committees is important.
Case study – Bracknell Forest Council | The constitutional role of the executive member for finance and corporate improvement
The executive member for finance and corporate improvement is responsible for:
1 .Overall performance and effective operation of the financial resources of the council, including accountancy services, payments, procurement, and income management. To have responsibility for the staff of the council, including their welfare, wellbeing, and relationship with the council.
2. The formulation of the Council’s annual revenue budget, and its implementation following its approval by Council.
3. The formulation of the Council’s annual capital budget, and its implementation following its approval by Council.
4. The powers and duties of the Council for the collection of local taxes, fee income, charges, and debt recovery.
5. Financial (including investment and insurance) management, and management of the Council’s balances.
6. The procurement processes and practises within the council. This to include the procurement obligation to obtain social value for the council’s purchasing activities.
7. To act as lead Member in relation to risk management and audit responsibilities which are not covered by the Governance and Audit committee
8. To be the joint Executive Member for the council’s property joint venture. Holding a board role on the Cambium Partnership.
9. The Executive Member for the Business Change programme and Corporate Improvement.
10. Employee relations, and staff well-being and welfare. Relationship with Trades Unions, employee associations and staff networks. To be the link with the national pay bodies and employer groups.
11. Staff training and development. To lead on being an employer of choice (recruitment, retention, and staff performance management). Staff apprenticeships and being a learning organisation.
12. Any functions under the resources and finance responsibility which are Executive Functions, and which do not fall within the remit of another Executive portfolio.
13. To represent the Council on, and to liaise with, external organisations delivering services directly impacting on or related to the portfolio for which the Executive Member is responsible.
[Source: Bracknell Forest Council, Council Constitution, updated August 2024]
Governance arrangements and finance
The next level of understanding of financial governance is to understand how finance is discussed, determined, and delivered within the wider governance system. There are two illustrations below: the first is a simplified cabinet-based governance system, and the second is a simplified committee system. For any governance system ask yourself, ‘how is financial information provided? Who is it provided to? When? How does the budgetary cycle fit into the political management arrangements? Who can challenge on financial issues?’
A system-wide analysis highlights the role that other councillors can play, for example:
- the full council is the sovereign body of a council, and all councillors have a role in debating and agreeing the budget and policy framework
- the 'overview and scrutiny' function in a council with the cabinet governance model (or in a committee system which contains an overview and scrutiny function) is a statutory function which has the power to scrutinise a council's finances and budgets
- audit committees have a role in providing independent assurance on the integrity of the financial reporting and governance processes
- opposition parties will often seek to contest and challenge council finances and budgets and, sometimes, propose alternative budgets
Challenge 3 – Mapping your political management system and the link to finance
Step 1: Council-wide map
Produce your own ‘map’ or illustration of your council’s governance arrangements in relation to budget-setting, monitoring, and assurance.
Then spend some time considering the following questions:
- Where does ‘finance’ sit in your political management arrangements?
- What are the specific roles of the different parts of the governance system in finance leadership and management and financial assurance?
- What works well? What doesn’t?
- How do ‘decisions’ work through the system? Who is involved? What is the balance between member and officer involvement? How are finances assessed, reported, and challenged at different points in the decision-making process? Where does challenge come from?
- What future changes might impact on the governance of finance?
Step 2: Portfolio-specific map
In Step 2, consider how the map works in your portfolio or service area. You may want to add more detail to your map or to produce a second portfolio specific illustration.
Then consider the following:
- How do issues relating to your portfolio or service finances and budgets flow through the political structures?
- What works? What does not?
- Could improvements be made?
Step 3: Analysis and actions
The final step is to consider:
- What have you learned by undertaking this challenge?
- What improvements could be made?
- What actions and next steps could be taken?